Deck Remodeling vs. New Deck Construction; Which is the Best Choice?

Deck Remodeling vs. New Deck Construction

Content updated July 7, 2023

Are you contemplating remodeling your existing deck or starting fresh with a brand-new one? Making this decision requires careful consideration of various factors. At Precision Homecrafters, we understand the dilemma homeowners face regarding deck projects. Let us shed light on the pros and cons of remodeling versus starting over, helping you make an informed choice.

Remodeling an existing deck can seem appealing, but critical aspects must be considered. Here’s an anecdote from one of our projects that highlights the importance of a solid foundation in deck construction:

We recently encountered a deck remodeling project where clients wanted us to freshen up their deck by replacing the decking boards alone. However, upon inspecting the support posts, we noticed significant concerns. We recognized the need for a sturdy foundation, so we advised tearing down the existing structure and starting anew. The clients were initially hesitant due to the perceived additional work and expenses, but we explained the reasoning behind our recommendation.

When evaluating whether to remodel or start over, keep the following points in mind:

Structural Integrity 

Existing decks may have support posts buried underground or set in concrete prone to moisture exposure, fungal growth, and decay. Starting over allows you to address these issues by building a solid foundation from the ground up.

Design Flexibility

Starting fresh opens up a world of design possibilities. You can create a deck that perfectly matches your vision, incorporating the latest trends, materials, and features.

Safety and Compliance

Building codes and regulations continually evolve to ensure the safety of deck structures. Starting over allows you to meet or exceed the latest standards, providing peace of mind and avoiding costly issues during inspections or resale.

Long-Term Durability

Remodeled decks may still have underlying issues that could resurface in the future. Starting over enables you to construct a deck with superior materials, such as double-treated bands and joists, ensuring longevity and minimizing maintenance needs.

At Precision Homecrafters, we emphasize a comprehensive approach to deck construction. Our process involves: 

  • Transparent Communication: Our experienced team provides honest feedback and expert recommendations based on your deck’s specific needs and desired outcomes.
  • Customized Solutions: Whether remodeling or starting over, we tailor our services to meet your preferences, budget, and timeline, ensuring a deck that exceeds your expectations.
  • Quality Craftsmanship: Our skilled professionals employ top-notch materials, modern construction techniques, and meticulous attention to detail to deliver a deck that stands the test of time.

When considering deck remodeling, it’s essential to think beyond surface-level improvements. You can make an informed decision by evaluating the condition of your support posts, the integrity of the existing structure, and the long-term goals for your deck. 

Remember, a deck built on a solid foundation guarantees aesthetic appeal, safety, durability, and lasting enjoyment for years to come. Contact us today for a consultation.